Skip to Main Content
Please enable JavaScript in your browser for better use of the website!
Home
Shop
Join Farm Club
Meet Your Farmers
Order Cut off Times
Bulk Meat: Whole, Half, Quarters
Farm Store
Recipes
Refer a Friend
Money Back Guarantee
Contact
Newsletter Sign Up
FREE HOME DELIVERY ON ALL ORDERS
Search...
0
•
$0
View cart
Checkout
0
Log in
Create an Account
Home
Shop
Beef
Pork
Baked Goods
Clothing
Dairy Products
Cheese
Tonics, Syrups, Fire Cider
Hot Sauce
BBQ Sauces
Maple Products
Seasonings
Honey
Salsas, Mustards, Sauces
Beauty Products
Eggs
Coffee
Jams
Pickled Products
Bundles
Join Farm Club
Meet Your Farmers
Order Cut off Times
Bulk Meat: Whole, Half, Quarters
Farm Store
Recipes
Refer a Friend
Money Back Guarantee
Contact
Newsletter Sign Up
Want $10 OFF your first order?
Let us email you a $10 off coupon for your first order!
E-Mail
Extra
Please enable JavaScript in your browser for better use of the website!
Cheese
Skip to Main Content
Sort + Filter
Show
12
24
36
48
Home
Shop
Cheese
Sort
Featured
Best Selling
$ → $$$$
$$$$ → $
A → Z
Z → A
Old → New
New → Old
Add to compare
Compare
Colby Jack
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to compare
Compare
8 YEAR OLD CHEDDAR
$10.99
Add to Cart
Add to compare
Compare
3 Year Old Sharp
$7.99
Add to Cart
Add to compare
Compare
Stoltzfus Cheese Curds
$5.99
Quick Shop
Add to compare
Compare
Stoltzfus Farmstead Cheese
$8.99
Quick Shop
Add to compare
Compare
Jake's Cheese
$8.99
Quick Shop
Add to compare
Compare
Cheese Spread
$5.99
Quick Shop
